Many people choose stationery by how each piece looks alone, forgetting they'll all be on the desk together.
A simple method
Lay out everything you use often and take a photo. If there are more than five highly saturated colors, your eye keeps jumping between them.
We eventually standardized our tapes and sticky notes on six muted colors for section marking. Fewer colors, clearer marking.
Not monotonous
Muted doesn't mean gray. Slate blue, oat, and mist green still have depth — they just don't shout.
Let the tools be quieter, so the ideas can be louder.